River View Alternative Processing

I have been trying to work out a way to digitally process my second-rate photos so as to salvage them.  Sometimes composition can be great, but there is nothing minor you can do to fix flat lighting, even in Photoshop.  This image is a good example (see original in previous post), and I spent yesterday working and reworking this image.  I came up with two versions that I liked, both heavily reworked in Photoshop.  I like them both for very different reasons.  Do you like the look of either of these?